Scarsdale looks to Singapore for the new math
By Swapna Venugopal Ramaswamy • The Journal News • October 9, 2008
...[T]he Scarsdale school district adopts Singapore math in kindergarten through fifth grade, replacing Trailblazers, used in the district for a decade.
The textbook series, written by the Ministry of Education of Singapore, is called Primary Mathematics, and Scarsdale is the first public school district to use it in New York as its core curriculum.
Until last year, the district used Trailblazers, textbooks aligned with the so-called reform mathematics - often derided as fuzzy math - based on recommendations originally published in 1989 by the influential National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
That approach called for a de-emphasis on manual arithmetic in favor of students' attention to the process leading to the answer. Math texts following the reform philosophy also have been criticized as covering too many topics in a haphazard sequence.
"The mainstream U.S. math curriculum is often seen as being a mile wide and an inch deep," said Nancy Pavia, the district's math helping teacher.
In 2006, the math council released the Curriculum Focal Points report, which identified important mathematical topics in each grade - from kindergarten through eighth - that students need to understand deeply and thoroughly for future mathematics learning.
This report was, at least in part, the result of the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study, an international assessment of the mathematics and science knowledge of fourth- and eighth-grade students around the world. The study found that students from many Asian countries outperformed their U.S. counterparts.
Of the 46 countries that participated in the study, U.S. eighth-graders ranked 15th in 2003. That was the nation's best score in the three years the study was conducted (in 1997 it was 28th), but it still was behind most other industrialized countries.
Singapore topped the list every time. Math taught in Singapore is part of a national curriculum designed by the Ministry of Education. It emphasizes the development of a strong number sense, mental-math skills and a deep understanding of place value.
"The curriculum is based on a progression from concrete experience, using manipulatives, to a pictorial stage and finally to the abstract level," Pavia said.
Last year, a 30-member committee of Scarsdale teachers and administrators reviewed the district's curriculum based on the Focal Points report.
[snip]
The new textbooks will look a lot "cleaner and clearer" compared with Trailblazers, which is heavily language-based.
"There will be fewer words on the pages, and it will be less confusing to students," she said.
Trailblazers used a "spiral approach," touching upon many concepts each year and revisiting the same topics in later grades, all while not learning them to mastery.
Cadalzo explains it thus: "In second grade, for instance, the children use multiplication tables from 2 to 5, but they haven't memorized them; and when they come to third grade, we end up relearning them. But now, they will have learned them in second grade and we can just concentrate on multiplication tables for 6, 7, 8 and 9."
The lack of drills in U.S. schools might help explain the popularity of the Japan-based Kumon tutoring centers, which have sprouted throughout the states as parents look for supplements to cement the basics. The Kumon math program focuses on drilling children on basics.
There are 1,500 Kumon centers in North America, including one in Scarsdale, home to a consistently high-performing school district.
"As an Asian mother, I am very happy with the new curriculum," said Indian-born and -raised Shobha Bhatnagar, mother of an Edgewood second-grader.
[snip]
Jeffrey Thomas, president of SingaporeMath.com, the Oregon-based U.S. distributor of Primary Mathematics since 1998, estimated that 1,000 schools nationally are using the books as a supplement, with 200 using them as their core curriculum.
"Initially, most of the demand came from parents of homeschooled children and the gifted and talented programs, but now it's the mainstream schools," he said. "We are very proud to add Scarsdale to the list. They are a class act."
[snip]
"Scarsdale is not a district to rest on its laurels. We are always looking to do even better," she said. "We want to give our students every opportunity to learn math to their full capacity because, ultimately, they will be competing in the global economy."
In the past, Cadalzo's students came to their own understanding of math through guided exploration, which he conceded they were more "likely to forget." But this year he planned to teach the basics until his students can "feel it in their bones."
Sofia Lacagnina sat at her desk flipping through the pages of the slim Primary Mathematics, and said, "Trailblazers was fatter and heavier. This book is thin. I love this book."
Reach Swapna Venugopal Ramaswamy at svenugop@lohud.com or 914-694-5004.
So.
Scarsdale gets Singapore Math.
Irvington gets Project Lead the Way.
That should prop up housing values in a crashing world economy.
That should prop up housing values in a crashing world economy.
ReplyDeleteWell, in Scarsdale it just might.
It sure makes me want to move to there.
"In second grade, for instance, the children use multiplication tables from 2 to 5, but they haven't memorized them; and when they come to third grade, we end up relearning them. But now, they will have learned them in second grade and we can just concentrate on multiplication tables for 6, 7, 8 and 9."
ReplyDeleteImagine, having a "secure" date in the same year that the material was taught!
" But this year he planned to teach the basics until his students can "feel it in their bones."
Apparently, mastery meant something else before.
"Irvington gets Project Lead the Way."
ReplyDeleteActually, this should have a big impact on surrounding school districts. This is no longer theoretical. They can't ignore it.
This is an amazing development; surely Scarsdale must be the first NYS suburban school district to adopt Singapore. This could help break down the barrier that public schools like my own have erected when they say Singapore doesn’t align with state standards.
ReplyDeleteYesterday I was at the Scarsdale Kumon center mentioned in the article, and I detected a slightly nervous laugh from the director when we discussed how this would affect his business. He said he might have to rethink his marketing plans in consideration of this development.
"He said he might have to rethink his marketing plan.."
ReplyDeleteOpen a center in Irvington.
It's also important that this is not a low SES area. They don't look at it as remedial. For example, our schools use phonics-based instruction if all else fails.
The whole thing is amazing -- particularly given the fact that Scarsdale's adoption of Trailblazers was influential in Irvington's adoption of Trailblazers.
ReplyDeleteI anticipate seeing the school board request that the administration address the question of Primary Mathematics and why we have not considered adopting it.
The assistant superintendent has already given her answer to this question, which is that Trailblazers is not the curriculum, because Irvington writes its own curriculum. Since Irvington writes its own curriculum, parents and taxpayers are misguided in complaining about Trailblazers.
She will also cite the high scores of last year's 6th graders on the state tests. Their scores prove Trailblazers is working. The fact that NY tests material far below the level mastered by students in Singapore will not be addressed. Nor will the fact that many of these kids were tutored or taught long division by their parents.
And, finally, she will point to the TriState Consortium report, which applauds Trailblazers.
If need be, the administration will cite the existence of parents who like Trailblazers.
Still, politically speaking it's a difficult spot for the administration to be in. There is tremendous unhappiness with the math department & curriculum, and this unhappiness cost the district votes on the last fields bond.
The best move would probably be for the administration to ask the Curriculum Committee to consider Singapore Math & have the committee issue a report acknowledging that Singapore Math is a good curriculum but noting that since Irvington writes its own curriculum we don't need it.