Bob Dixon on the worst textbook you could possibly imagine

What if Zig Engelmann set out intentionally to write the worst textbook he possibly could? ...If you think about it, Zig should be able to pull this off better than anyone alive. ...Extremely confusing concepts all would be introduced at the same time and/or in close approximation. Stuff would be "taught" and then dropped, or more accurately, "covered" and then dropped. New material being covered would logically require mastery of prerequisite knowledge that most of the students most likely wouldn't have.

[snip]

If Zig were to engage in this little heuristic exercise, the result, I believe, would be a textbook that would sell like crazy and generate a fortune in royalties, and it would take about one-twentieth of the time that it would take to write an instructionally sound textbook.... [T]his ... came to me while looking at my daughter's geometry textbook. The thought hit me that if Zig had tried to write the worst possible geometry textbook in the world, it would end up looking a lot like Emily's geometry text, published b one of the few major educational publishing companies still standing.

[snip]

Within two lessons of a single chapter of a best-selling geometry text, eight major, similar concepts are introduced, with eight more or less similar names or labels. Absolutely no one associated with this textbook ever took a single minute to look at all of this stuff through the eyes of the learner.

It's same ole, same ole. A few kids get A's on the tests, which passes as proof that the book is fine, but there is something wrong with the kids who flunk the test or get C's or D's. Zig could have written this book without having seen it just playing the game of trying to make everything as difficult and confusing as humanly possible. I've looked carefully for spots where Zig could, in fact, make the book worse than it is, but they are few and far between.

Isn't that strange? Really. You'd think that any best-selling textbook would get a few things right, would do a few things that actually take a student perspective into consideration. You'd think that Zig's horrible geometry text would be far worse than a best-selling geometry text. This is both astounding and depressing. Someone is making a fortune off a textbook that could be just slightly better than the worst textbook we could imagine, the worst textbook Zig could write. Get out the thesaurus: overwhelmed, dismayed, incredulous, confounded...

What Would You Get if You Set Out to Write the Worst Textbook You Could Possibly Imagine? A Best Seller
by Bob Dixon
Direct Instruction News
Spring 2008

Of course, I'd love to know what textbook he's talking about.

I was thinking Glencoe Geometry, but it can't be because the lead author on the textbook Dixon's talking about is a mathematician.

I just checked the author page for Glencoe Geometry & all 5 authors are math educators.


kitchen table math