Rubric Burn

My wife and I just got back from our 15 minute parent-teacher meeting. We might have seemed rude, but we couldn't chitchat. We dived right into our biggest concern - making sure that our son gets the rubric before working on the assignment, knowing the exact due date, and getting the results and grade back in a timely fashion so that we can go over them with our son. These things haven't been happening. Many assignments don't have rubrics. Our son can take some of the blame, but there needs to be a process that is designed to make it easy for us parents. They expect involved parents, but they have to give us the tools.

The big issue was about rubrics for individual assignments and for overall grades. Our rubrics go from 1 - 5. I don't think anyone gets a 1 and kids only get 5s if, well, I don't know why and his teacher couldn't really explain when or why. I told her that 5s seem to something like an A+. She said it was more than that. The kids have to show how their assignment is somehow related or integrated with other subjects in an abstract way. Of course, the school doesn't teach them about this or show them how to do this. Some rubrics do tell the students what they have to do to get a 5, but there is always the proviso that there has to be something more. What that more is, they never say. I told the teacher that kids want to get 5s but they aren't taught how. She really didn't have much to say other than (in so many words) "That's the point".

A 3 indicates that the student is meeting state expectations. I told her that I have seen the state expectations and tests and consider a 3 to be a 'C' grade. She seemed surprised to hear me say that. I'm not sure why. A 2 grade indicated (in a very broad sense) that there is a problem that needs to be fixed. A 2 is a 'D' grade.

That leaves the 4 grade to cover the range of 'B' to 'A'. Some teachers have suggested that rubrics are just another form of grading like A, B, C, and D. They aren't. They are non-linear and very poorly defined. Kids struggle to get 5s because they think that it's an 'A'. My son can't always explain why he gets a 3, 4, or 5 on an assignment or test. Grades are supposed to give students some sort of feedback to help them with future assignments. This is not happening.

Even math tests are translated into rubric grades of 1 - 5. My son hasn't had enough graded assignments for me to plot rubric grade against percent correct on his tests. I'm betting that the relationship is nonlinear. The math teacher doesn't allow the test to go home. It has to go into their portfolio and stay at school. Don't they think these things through? I'd like to give them a rubric.