kitchen table math, the sequel: game on

Wednesday, May 23, 2007

game on

Yesterday we were sent an email bearing the Village budget report by a member of the new "citizen's oversight committee."

Ed and I both suspect unauthorized use of an email list or two.

Here's the text:

please take particular note of the Police Budget on pages 12-15 as it is getting the most amount of press

<> I am sending this out as a citizen of Irvington--not as my role as a member of the CBC
my intent is not to advocate a viewpoint--but to disseminate this report --I know how busy people are and many will not access the link to retrieve

As far as the content--I believe the report speaks volumes and it is up to you THE TAXPAYERS OF IRVINGTON TO SEND A MESSAGE TO YOUR MAYOR AND BOARD OF TRUSTEES --IF YOU HAVE AN INTEREST IN YOUR TAXES AND HOW THEY CAN AFFECT YOUR QUALITY OF LIFE IN OUR VILLAGE

YOU NOW HAVE THE INFORMATION AND I HOPE THE INCLINATION TO COMMUNICATE YOUR VIEWS TO THE BOARD

HERE ARE THE EMAIL ADDRESSES TO VOICE YOUR OPINION to the mayor and board of trustees-I know many people cannot make the budget meetings in the evenings--

I haven't looked at the report (train wreck! train wreck!) but Ed did. Irvington, a village of roughly 6500 has, I believe, 77 full-time employees. Something like that. We have 27 policemen & women. Our crossing guards are policemen paid $80,000/yr; same deal with the people handing out parking tickets. The town is losing money on parking tickets, as a matter of fact, because we pay a policeman $80,000 to distribute them.

Village employees shovel snow and rake leaves, collecting overtime as needed. Which is particularly annoying to Ed and me, seeing as how we live on a "private road," meaning a road so private no one knows who owns it. Our road isn't maintained by the Village; it is called "the bumpy road" as a direct result. We pay for our own snowploughing & we rake our own leaves, etc. Sort of the same way parents in the school system pay for their own teachers.

There are a lot of private roads in Irvington, as it turns out -- and all of the folks who live on them are paying for town services privately.

People have been talking about the possibility of a tax revolt in Irvington.

After reading the budget report last night, Ed came upstairs and said, "It's already begun."

First the fields emails; now this one.



letter to the editor:

The local paper published this letter from me a day or two before the school board election & budget vote:

5-7-2007

To the editor:

The Irvington school district has the right mission statement – to create a challenging and supportive learning environment in which each student attains his or her highest potential for academic achievement – but too little sense of mission.

In math, the international standard for all students is algebra in the 8th grade. Yet here in Irvington, only 30% of students take algebra in 8th grade, and many of these students are being tutored or taught at home by parents.

Or compare IUFSD to the KIPP Academy, a charter school in the Bronx serving disadvantaged black and Hispanic children. Eighty percent of KIPP’s 8th graders take algebra and pass Regents Math A.

Per pupil spending at KIPP: roughly $10,000 per student

Per pupil spending at IUFSD: $21,000

One fourth of our eighth graders are invited to take Earth Science in the 8th grade; Pelham teaches Earth Science to all of its 8th grade students, including students in special ed.

The 7th grade ELA curriculum assigns books with measured reading levels of 5th and 6th grades; the social studies curriculum calls for students to make PowerPoint presentations; the Spanish class requires students to spend their weekends cutting out pictures of clothing from magazines and pasting them onto a piece of paper with labels in Spanish.

In K-5, Math TRAILBLAZERS takes more time to teach less content, and the district has deliberately slowed the progress of mathematically gifted children over the strenuous objections of their parents. Gifted children are to be “enriched,” not accelerated.

Enrichment means asking children to solve simple algebra problems without teaching them algebra.

Last but not least, I am still waiting for an explanation of last year’s bell curve exercise at the middle school. (Some) sixth grade teachers drew bell curves on their whiteboards, explained to students that they were average, and told them they should consider the Cs they would be receiving a good grade.

After the vote on May 15, Irvington’s school board will need to direct its immediate energies to getting a compromise fields project underway.

But I believe that, as work on “Plan B” proceeds, our elected representatives can also begin the process of holding administrators accountable for making our school mission statement a reality.

Catherine Johnson

From what I can see, the whole town - school & village - is a slide and glide operation.

6 comments:

Catherine Johnson said...

Ed says the Irvington police are apparently getting 54 days of vacation a year.

Maybe it's all the town employees.

LynnG said...

Oh good heavens!

27 police officers?

Do you have the world's highest crime rate for a village of 6300?

My town is barely over 10,000 people and I think we have something like 7 officers plus the chief.

At the budget hearings in March, the Board of Selectmen went line by line through the budget. They actually questioned an increase in the line item to purchase bullets.

I was so impressed. It was the first time I had seen responsible governance.

We had a tax revolt about 10 to 15 years ago, that's probably why stuff is so transparent now. Something about a garbage hauling contract set it off. The budget was voted down repeatedly as voters declared their unwillingneww to put up with the nonsense.

Taxpayer revolts are always a good thing.

That's my motto.

Catherine Johnson said...

Can you vote on your town budget?

We can't.

We have... 3.7 crimes a year.

Something like that.

LynnG said...

Voting on the town budget is an art form. This is New England after all.

It came as quite a shock after my Mid-Western upbringing.

In February, during public meetings, the finance board establishes a "guideline" for the other two operating boards to follow in their budget prep.

At the first public meeting in March, each of those Boards presents their proposed budget. Public workshops are held weekly (or more) for as long as it takes to slog through.

These are really quick at our Board of Ed as few people show up, much less ask questions.

Then in April, informational sessions are held, culminating in a town meeting where questions went on for hours (and is televised, thank you public access). People complained that Town vehicles were too new, or had to many bells and whistles, the Town manager and Superintendent field many questions. It can get heated.

Finally we vote. If the budget fails to pass by a 2/3 margin, it goes to referendum. It continues to go to referendum until it passes.

It's really amazing. I highly recommend it.

Catherine Johnson said...

Finally we vote. If the budget fails to pass by a 2/3 margin, it goes to referendum. It continues to go to referendum until it passes.

It's really amazing. I highly recommend it.


We need this.

We also need to defeat a school budget.

That's not going to be easy - though most parents don't realize that defeating a school budget simply means your tax increases les than it was going to under the budget.

(By law we got to an "alternative" budget if we vote down the proposed budget.)

Catherine Johnson said...

The new assistant super has severely let me down.

She's not going to provide answer keys; says it would be "unusual."

I've written a response; won't post it here for awhile...

Have to call her later on.

$21,000 and the kids can't have the answer key.

Which taxpayers paid for.